George Sanders as Jaffrey Pyncheon

Margaret Lindsay as Hepzibah Pyncheon

Vincent Price as Clifford Pyncheon

Nan Grey as Phoebe Pyncheon

Dick Foran as Matthew Maule

Cecil Kellaway as Philip Barton

Alan Napier as Fuller

Gilbert Emery as Gerald Pyncheon

Miles Mander as Deacon Arnold Foster

Charles Trowbridge as Judge

Harry Cording as Blacksmith Hawkins

Michael Mark as Ex-Convict

Hal Budlong as Driver

Caroline Frances Cooke as Town Gossip

Kernan Cripps as Workman

Robert Dudley as Jury Foreman

Martin Faust as Town Gossip

Margaret Fealy as Town Gossip

Sibyl Harris as Mrs. Foster

Ellis Irving as Man Drinking From Cup

P.J. Kelly as Man With Rake

Colin Kenny as Court Bailiff

Ann Kunde as Courtroom Spectator

Jane Loofbourrow as Town Gossip

Murdock MacQuarrie as Town Gossip

Michael Mark as Ex-Convict Reading Tribune

Nelson McDowell as Coroner in Courtroom

Mira McKinney as Mrs. Reynolds

Edgar Norton as Phineas Weed - Jaffrey's Servant

Lon Poff as Juror

Russ Powell as Grocer / Juror

Allen D. Sewall as Juror

Jack C. Smith as Prison Guard

Hugh Sothern as Reverend Jeremiah Smith

Harry Stubbs as Jeremiah - Man in Pub

Claire Whitney as Witness

Harry Woods as Mr. Wainwright