Kelly Stables as Athena / Puffy (voice)

Vicki Lewis as Drizelda (voice)

Jim Cummings as Haldorf (voice)

Laraine Newman as Elf Elder's Wife (voice)

Greg Ellis as Tin (voice)

Jess Harnell as Pan (voice)

Richard McGonagle as Alley (voice)

Wayne Knight as The Elf Elder (voice)

Dee Bradley Baker as Buster / Elf Boy (voice)