James Franco as Michael Glatze

Zachary Quinto as Bennett

Emma Roberts as Rebekah Fuller

Daryl Hannah as Deborah

Lesley Ann Warren as Susan

Avan Jogia as Nico

Charlie Carver as Tyler

Devon Graye as Cory

Evie Thompson as Nicole

Leven Rambin as Catherine

Ahna O'Reilly as Actress

Jefferson Mays as Preacher Teacher

Jan Maxwell as Coltry

Nick Rehberger as Adam

Kevin Cahoon as Peter

Blake Lee as Benoit Denizet-Lewis

Jacob Loeb as Teddy

Daniel Polo as Paul

Deidre Goodwin as Cheryl

Blake Young-Fountain as Chris

Vince Jolivette as Pastor Mike

Jenna Leigh Green as Emergency Room Doctor

Amelia Campbell as Judy Shepard

Patrick Page as Bible Teacher

Lance Roberts as Bishop

Eva Augustina Sinotte as Sexy Lady / Eva

Juan Castano as Anthony

Kanoa Goo as Bible Student

Anna Myrha as Buddhist Advisor

Joe Baken as Jeremy

Jaime Cepero as Kid

Ruthie Ann Miles as Kid

Raymond T. Williams as Heart Specialist

Sophie Savides as Crying Girl

Ella Dershowitz as Liberty Student 1

Reema Sampat as Liberty Student 2

Anna Suzuki as Drunk Friend 1

Anni Weisband as Drunk Friend 2

Patrick John Fagan as Paul's Boyfriend

Allie Gallerani as Derica

Laura Ling as News Reporter