David Warner as Eugene Devlin

Tom Sizemore as Randy

Bonnie Wright as Phoebe

Cynthia Gibb as Caroline

Eric Roberts as David

Alice St. Clair as Zooey

Chevy Chase as Gravedigger

James Rebhorn as Priest

Jamie Bamber as Paul

Eugene Simon as Young Eugene - aged 20

Campbell Scott as Young Eugene - aged 48

Sasha Spielberg as Rachel

Tanner Flood as Child Eugene

Clare Foley as Child Phoebe

Caley Chase as Geena

Daniel Edwin Adams as Parishioner

John Blyth Barrymore as Pianist

Rusty De Wees as Nurse

Chris Lamica as Second Worker

Eva Schiffman as Little Girl

George Woodard as Singer

Tara Arielle O'Reilly as Neighbor