Keir Gilchrist as The Stranger

Pollyanna McIntosh as Bobbie

Sam Witwer as Hank

Booboo Stewart as Isaac

Adrienne Barbeau as The Radio DJ

Gracie Gillam as Alice

Jose Pablo Cantillo as Dutch

Lin Shaye as Lynn's Mother

Greg Grunberg as Alex Mathis

Adam Green as Carlo (Cop #2)

Barry Bostwick as Mr. Abbadon

John Landis as Jebediah Rex

James Duval as Dante

Ben Woolf as Rusty Rex

Barbara Crampton as Darla (The Witch)

Noah Segan as Bart

Kristina Klebe as Detective McNally

Robert Rusler as Mr. Blake

Alex Essoe as Lynn

Joe Dante as Prof. Milo Gottlieb

Pat Healy as Forensic Bob

Caroline Williams as Mrs. Blake

Stuart Gordon as Sherlock Holmes

Dana Gould as Boris

Marc Senter as Jack

Mick Garris as The Phantom

Adrianne Curry as Adrianne Curry

Tiffany Shepis as Maria

Trent Haaga as Nelson

Lisa Marie as The Victorian Widow

Felissa Rose as Parent

Cerina Vincent as Ellen Bishop

John Savage as Capt. J.G. Zimmerman

Elissa Dowling as Velma

Jack Dylan Grazer as Young Stranger

Austin Falk as Kyle (segment "Sweet Tooth")

Madison Iseman as Lizzy

Axelle Carolyn as Background

Ben Stillwell as Todd (segment “The Night Billy Raised Hell”)

Lombardo Boyar as Gambling Neighbor

Natalie Castillo as Britney

Lucas Armendariz as Lone Child (segment "Ding Dong")

Hart Keathley as Child Astronaut (segment "Ding Dong")

Aidan Gail as Child Fireman (segment "Ding Dong") / Kevin (segment "Bad Seed")

Gavin Keathley as Child Jake Gyllenhal (segment "Ding Dong")

Andy Merrill as Neighbor

Sean Clark as Tytan

Daniel DiMaggio as Mikey (segments "Sweet Tooth" & "Ding Dong"

Rafael Jordan as Alien (segment “The Night Billy Raised Hell”)

Greg McLean as Ray Bishop

Hunter Smit as Timothy Blake

Clare Kramer as Lt. Brandt-Mathis

Marcus Eckert as Billy (segment "The Night Billy Raised Hell")

Christophe Zajac-Denek as Mordecai / The Little Devil (segment "The Night Billy Raised Hell")

Adam Pascal as The Dentist (segment "The Night Billy Raised Hell")

John F. Beach as James (segment "Trick")

Casey Ruggieri as Maria (segment "Trick")

Marnie McKendry as Princess (segment "Trick") (as Marnie MckEndry)

Rebekah McKendry as Mother (segment "Trick") (as Rebekah MckEndry)

Mia Page as Girl - Witch (segment "Trick" & "Ding Dong")

Clay Keller as Alien (segment "Trick") (as Clayton Keller)

Kennedy Fuselier as "Gypsy" AKA "Cinderella" (segment "Trick")

Sage Stewart as Devil (segment "Trick") / Devil Girl (segment "Ding Dong")

Bianca Rose Miller as Little Girl (segment "Trick") (as Bianca Miller)

Liesel Hanson as Mary Bailey (segment "Grim Grinning Ghost")

V Nixie as Mary Bailey (segment "Grim Grinning Ghost")

Anubis as Baby (segment "Grim Grinning Ghost")

Lilly von Woodenshoe as Gretel (segment "Ding Dong")

Vanessa Menendez as Lone Child's Mother (segment "Ding Dong")

Melissa 'Mo' Meinhart as Witch / Bobbie's Hand / Arm Double (segment "Ding Dong") (as Mo Meinhardt)

Katie Silverman as Young Alice (segment "The Weak and the Wicked")

Matt Merchant as The Demon (segment "The Weak and the Wicked")

Graham Denman as Ziggy (segment "This Means War")

Thomas Blake, Jr. as Axl (segment "This Means War") (as Thomas Blake)

Buz Wallick as Danzy (segment "This Means War")

Joshua Lou Friedman as Butch (segment "This Means War")

Jennifer Wenger as Vicki / Possessed Dorothy (segments "This Means War" & "Friday the 31st")

Michael Monterastelli as Goober (segment "This Means War") (as Michael Monterestelli)

Graham Skipper as Cop / Hellman (segments "This Means War" & "Bad Seed")

Cody Goodfellow as Drunken Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Frank Blocker as Judge Mustache (segment "This Means War")

Andy Merrill as Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Frank Dietz as Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Noel Jason Scott as Nosferatu (segment "This Means War")

Shaked Berenson as Detective, Mexican Wrestler (segment "This Means War")

Amanda Moyer as Dorothy (segment "Friday the 31st")

Nick Principe as Killer (segment "Friday the 31st")

Dana Renee Ashmore as Coroner #1 (segment "Bad Seed")

Dylan Struzan as Coroner #2 (segment "Bad Seed")

Drew Struzan as Rembrandt (segment "Bad Seed")

Nicole Laino as Cheryl (segment "Bad Seed")

Monette Moio as Cheerleader Girl (segment "Bad Seed")

Noah Nevins as Cheerleader Boyfriend (segment "Bad Seed")

Alexandra Fritz as Pirate (segment "Bad Seed")

Halie Aquino as Background

Gloria Bradbury as Alien (segment "Ding Dong")

Lexi Brandy as Little Girl's Mom (segment "Ding Dong")

Andy Casillas as Piggy (segment "The Weak and the Wicked")

Heather Ashley Chase as Dectective Gemma (The Bad Seed )

Shawna Cupples as Background

Rick Galiher as Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Steven Gonzales as Parent (segment "Ding Dong")

Paula Haifley as Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Aaron Kai as Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

River Keathley as Little Girl (segment "Ding Dong")

Brandon Lamberty as Background

Rebecca Lord as Background Neighbor (segment "This Means War")

Michelle Parkman as Parent (segment "Ding Dong")

Aja Preston as Background

Clint Sears as Background

Jackson Stewart as Background

Serinity Thomas as Background

Yindra Zayas as Background

Axelle Carolyn as Background (uncredited)

A.J. Meyers as Young Bart (segment "The Weak and the Wicked") (uncredited)