Sebastián Silva as Freddy

Kristen Wiig as Polly

Tunde Adebimpe as Mo

Reg E. Cathey as The Bishop

Mark Margolis as Richard

Agustín Silva as Chino

Alia Shawkat as Wendy

Lillias White as Cecilia

Anthony Chisholm as Mo's Father

Marsha Stephanie Blake as Mo's Sister / Haimy

William Oliver Watkins as Mo's Brother-in-Law

Constance Shulman as Bishop's Girlfriend

Neal Huff as Gallery Owner

Jesse Thurston as Gallery Owner Assistant

Catrina Ganey as Policewoman

Toni D'Antonio as Nurse

Judy Marte as Abused Woman

Becky London as Jewish Woman

Cara Seymour as Nosy Neighbor

Ina Howard-Parker as Brooklyn Mom

Nico Arge as Nico

Emily Ann Garcia as Home Buyer (uncredited)

Cruz Rodriguez as Child (uncredited)