Anya Taylor-Joy as Thomasin

Ralph Ineson as William

Kate Dickie as Katherine

Harvey Scrimshaw as Caleb

Ellie Grainger as Mercy

Lucas Dawson as Jonas

Julian Richings as Governor

Bathsheba Garnett as The Witch

Sarah Stephens as The Witch, Young

Daniel Malik as Black Phillip (voice)

Axtun Henry Dube as Samuel

Athan Conrad Dube as Samuel

Vivien Moore as Lead Coven Witch

Karen Kaeja as Coven Witch

Brandy Leary as Coven Witch

Rebecca Hope Terry as Coven Witch

Carrie Eklund as Coven Witch

Madlen Sopadzhiyan as Coven Witch

Paul Kenworthy as Militia Man 1

Mark Millmna as Militia Man 2

Andy Volpe as Militia Man 3

Phillip Wynne as Wampanoag Man

Annawon Weeden as Wampanoag Man

Michael O'Hare as Pipe Smoker

Chris Messier as Shepherd

Ron Young as Old Slater

Nora Messier as Shepherdess

Bill Rudder as Settler

Grace Duffy as Settler

Sophie Bermudez as Settler

Corrine Manning as Settler

Heather Huntington Stewart as Chamber Pot Woman

Jeff Smith as Nobelman (uncredited)