Ray Bolger as Barnaby

Tommy Sands as Tom Piper

Annette Funicello as Mary Contrary

Ed Wynn as Toymaker

Tommy Kirk as Grumio

Kevin Corcoran as Boy Blue

Henry Calvin as Gonzorgo

Gene Sheldon as Roderigo

Mary McCarty as Mother Goose

Ann Jillian as Bo Peep

Brian Corcoran as Willie Winkie

Jack Donohue as Sylvester J. Goose (uncredited)

Bryan Russell as The Little Boy (uncredited)

Thurl Ravenscroft as Trees (singing voice)

Candy Candido as Trees (singing voice)

Bess Flowers as Villager (uncredited)

Leon Alton as Villager (uncredited)

Bernard Sell as Villager (uncredited)

James Gonzalez as Villager (uncredited)

Don Anderson as Villager (uncredited)