Seth Peterson as Robbie Levinson

Bruce Davison as Pastor Boyd

Chad Donella as Chris Boyd

Cindy Pickett as Barbara McCoy

Brian J. Smith as Trey McCoy

Susan Blakely as Martha Boyd

Lin Shaye as Kathleen Slansky

Farah White as Det. Elizabeth Fisher

Giancarlo Esposito as Detective Esposito

Sean Hennigan as Jim McCoy

Brandy Little as Stella

Ben Bathman as Connor Davis

Luke King as Alton Kachim

Earl Browning III as Detective Loy

Scarlett McAlister as Doctor Kucera

Connor Gewin as 4-year-old Trey

Tyler Farris as 10-year-old Trey

Trevor Sterling Stovall as Fisher's Son

Jason Hair-Wynn as Boy in Jail (uncredited)

Preston Strother as Boy in Church (uncredited)

Tyler Strother as Boy in Church (uncredited)

Cyrus Thompson as Boy in the Park (uncredited)

Tom Marcantel as Father Tim

Hana Kapp as Salesperson

Cas Dodgen as Policeman

Brock Cravy as Young Man

Kellie Rasberry as Carla, Robbie's Coworker

Dee Hennigan as Daycare Teacher

Keni LaTronico as Robbie's Mother (as Keni la Troncio)

Vernon Reeves as Seth's Father

Juan Gonzalez as Private Investigator

Heidie as Phoebe

Libby Villari as Shirley

Delia Rose as Church Member (as Delia Johnson)

Jenn Wright as Church Officer #1

Joe L. Blevins as Deacon (uncredited)

Nathan Childs as Police Officer (uncredited)

Phil Harrington as Doctor on Ward (uncredited)

Aaron Holt as CSI Agent (uncredited)

Christopher Holt as Sunday School Boy (uncredited)

Jennifer Holt as Child on Playground (uncredited)

Kevin Holt as Day Care Boy (uncredited)

Nicole Holt as Detective / Funeral Guest (uncredited)

Phillip Lanier as Choir Singer (uncredited)

Tiffany McManus as Sunday School Kid (uncredited)

Jimmy Paleschic as Crime Scene Investigator (uncredited)

Sloane Schoeneberg as Church Member (uncredited)

Summer Selby as Precinct Worker (uncredited)