Denis Leary as Mr. Beal

Joseph Cross as Joshua Beal

Rosie O'Donnell as Sister Terry

Dana Delany as Mrs. Beal

Timothy Reifsnyder as Dave O'Hara

Camryn Manheim as Sister Sophia

Julia Stiles as Neena Beal

Dan Lauria as Father Peters

Robert Loggia as Grandpa Beal

Stefan Niemczyk as Frank Benton

Michael Shulman as Robert Brickman

Marc H. Glick as Father Sebastian

Joey Perillo as Mr. Waltman

Jerry Walsh as Football Coach

Heather Casler as Hope