Jerry Lawler as Self

Peter Senerchia as Self / Taz

Michael Manna as Self / Big Stevie Cool

Óscar Gutiérrez as Self / Rey Mysterio

Gary Wolfe as Pitbull #1 (archive footage)

Anthony Durante as Pitbull #2 (archive footage)

Scott Levy as Raven (archive footage)

Dionicio Castellanos as Psychosis (archive footage)

John Watson as Mikey Whipwreck (archive footage)

Jim Fullington as The Sandman (archive footage)

Charles Scaggs as 2 Cold Sorpio (archive footage)

Terry Brunk as Sabu (archive footage)

Scott Bigelow as Bam Bam Bigelow (archive footage)

Rob Szatkowski as Rob Van Dam (archive footage)

Jeremy Lynn as Jerry Lynn (archive footage)

Chris Benoit as Chris Benoit (archive footage)

Eddie Guerrero as Eddie Guerrero (archive footage)

Steve Austin as Steve Austin (archive footage)

Paul Heyman as Self