Sienna Miller as Deb Callahan

Christina Hendricks as Kath

Aaron Paul as Chris

Will Sasso as Terry

Sky Ferreira as Bridget Callahan

Pat Healy as Ray

Alex Neustaedter as Tyler Hanrick

E. Roger Mitchell as Det. Sergeant Morris

Kentucker Audley as Brett Tobeck

Aidan McGraw as Jesse (Age 7)

Aidan Fiske as Jesse (Age 13)

Amy Madigan as Peggy

Alexander Joseph Wildes as Jesse (Age 1)

Maximus Thomas Wildes as Jesse (Age 1)

Katie Elinoff as Cindy

Rene Cadet as Paul

Gavin Earle as Murph (Age 10)

Kobi Polisky as Patrick (Age 8)

Adrianne Krstansky as Carol Hanrick

Kelly Rose Golden as Jenna Cunningham

Bates Wilder as Detective O'Brien

Chet Harding as Local News Reporter

Gwen Callahan as Mrs. Clancy

Karen Elverson as Mrs. Caponi

Rosemary Mahoney as Mrs. Hastings

Maggie Castle as Brett's Wife

Dennis Staroselsky as Professor Walters

Tyler Wesley Parrish as Murph (Age 16)

Jack Brunault as Patrick (Age 14)

Maggie Budzyna as Colleen

Dottie Reid as Aunt Dottie

Jack Reid as Uncle Jack

Christopher Hickey as Priest

Rebecca Gibel as Nursing Assistant #1

Georgia Lyman as Nursing Assistant #2

Nancy Villone as Shawna

Matt Merritt as Murph (Age 21)

Logan Hallowell as Patrick (Age 18)

Sarah Amber Newcomb as Sarah

Dee Nelson as Mrs. Coates

Gillian Mariner Gordon as Derrick Daughter

Rachel Singer as Mrs. Derrick

Joseph Oliveira as Man at the House (uncredited)

Lexie Roth as Search Party Member (uncredited)

Danielle Lyons as Search Party Volunteer (uncredited)

Michael Marchand as Police Officer (uncredited)

Tom Mariano as Search Party Member (uncredited)

Mazen Elkot as Customer (uncredited)

Travis Starr as Football Fan (uncredited)

Lisa Wynn as Football Game Spectator (uncredited)