Logan Miller as Ethan

Keir Gilchrist as Sean

James Caan as Harold Grainey

Bailey Noble as Carly

Lili Reinhart as Ashley

Edwin Hodge as Officer Palmer

Laura Innes as Caroline

Anne Dudek as Elise

Mindy Sterling as Mae

Tamlyn Tomita as Heather Cromwell

Nik Dodani as Sanjay

Dean Cameron as Defense Attorney

William Charles Mitchell as Judge

Billy Khoury as Neighbor

Ted King as Sean's Father

Luke Spencer Roberts as Ted Spiegelman

Elyse Dinh as Reporter #1

Hannah Elise Pilkington as Reporter 3

Christina Alex as Court Stenographer

Francesca Ling as Young Woman

Herbert Centeno as Court attendee / Paparazzi

Leonel Claude as Court Attendee

Christopher Clausi as Court attendee

Tonya Guadalupe as Court Attendee

Joey Hartstone as Juror

Fred Huguez as Jury Member

Kimbrey Jones as Jury Member

Kyle Mosonyi as Court Attendee

Ela Necker as Sean's Mom

Dennis Nicomede as Juror

Selena O'Sullivan as Juror

Pablo Ramos as Court Attendee

Mark Rossignol as Court spectator / press

Elvira Safiulina as Reporter

Katherine Stephens-Miller as Neighbor

Terry Stroud as Court Attendee

Rudolph Whitcomb as Prosecution Attorney

Pamela Drake Wilson as Court Reporter