Michael Reilly Burke as Ted Bundy

Boti Bliss as Lee

Tracey Walter as Randy Myers

Deborah Offner as Beverly

Tom Savini as Salt Lake City Detective

Tiffany Shepis as Tina Gabler

Julianna McCarthy as Professor

Steffani Brass as Julie

Matt Hoffman as Arnie

Renee Intlekofer as Cutler

Phoebe Dollar as Richardson

Marina Black as Kate

Alexa Jago as Betty

Jennifer Tisdale as Pretty Girl

Michael Santos as Man at Window

Annalee Autumn as Girl Attacked on Street

Eric DaRe as Male Partygoer

Melissa Schmidt as Female Party Goer

Orly Tepper as Dead Girl in Woods

Susan Featherly as Bundy Victim

Alexa Nikolas as I'm Ted Kid

Jesse Rutherford as I'm Ted Kid

Katrina Miller as Gilchrest