Jesse Metcalfe as Tom Endler

Robin Givens as Principal Kinney

Melissa Joan Hart as Grace Wesley

Brad Heller as School Attorney

Ernie Hudson as Judge Stennis

Hayley Orrantia as Brooke Thawley

Pat Boone as Walter Wesley

Paul Kwo as Martin Yip

Trisha LaFache as Amy Ryan

Jon Lindstrom as Superintendent Jim Powell

María Canals-Barrera as Catherine Thawley

Benjamin Ochieng as Reverend Jude

Sadie Robertson as Marlene

Fred Thompson as Senior Pastor

David A.R. White as Pastor Dave Hill

Ray Wise as Peter Kane

Tommy Blaze as Waiter

Rice Broocks as Rice Broocks

Mallory Hardin Brooks as Susan Stone

Natalie Canerday as Mrs. Rizzo

Ron Clemens as Rev. Dave Double

Verda Davenport as First Teacher

Abigail Duhon as Jessica

Taylor Eaves as Goth Girl

Kayla Esmond as Crazy Cat Lady

Mary Faulkner as Frazzled Teacher

Jenn Gotzon Chandler as Fashionista

Gary Habermas as Gary Habermas

Lauren Harper as Sunny Barista

Candyce Hinkle as Salvation Army Lady

Mike Huckabee as Mike Huckabee

Andres Hudson as Bailiff

Mark Whitman Johnson as County Clerk

Corey Koteras as Slacker Kid

Mario Luna as Prospective Juror

Travis McCoy as Male Journalist

Eamonn McCrystal as Simon Boyle

Gary Newton as Paramedic

Vivian Norman as Norma

Chanley Painter as V.P. of Teachers Union

Taylor Quick as Teenage Girl

Paige Martin Reynolds as Pharmacist

Kimberly Scott as Female Juror

Gianna Simone as Elizabeth Healy

John Stiritz as Older Man

Lee Strobel as Lee Strobel

Ryk St. Vincent as Jury Forman

J. Warner Wallace as Jim Warner Wallace

Jesse Wang as Martin's Father

Michael Tait as The Newsboys

Duncan Phillips as The Newsboys

Jeff Frankenstein as The Newsboys

Jody Davis as The Newsboys

Cara Alvey as Concert Patron (uncredited)

Danny Campbell as Jury Extra (uncredited)

Gregory Chisley as Courtroom observer (uncredited)

Brock Clyburn as Medical Staff (uncredited)

Ann Cogswell as Food Truck Patron (uncredited)

Margaret Cogswell as Gallery Observer (uncredited)

Greg Fallon as Lawyer (uncredited)

Kenneth Gaddie as Protestor (uncredited)

Latiera Golliday as Waitress (uncredited)

Lauren Hall as Extra (uncredited)

Mary Handiboe as Courtroom Observer (uncredited)

Bryan Harp as Paramedic (uncredited)

Spencer Kane Hess as Student (trouble maker) (uncredited)

Brent Holt as Protester Shaking Jesse Metcalfe Hand (uncredited)

Misty Jezierski as Supporter (uncredited)

D. Matt Jordan as Juror #6 (uncredited)

Chuck King as Background (uncredited)

James Mainard O'Connell as Timid Pastor (uncredited)

Star McCann as Courtroom Observer / Protester (uncredited)

Angela Sherrill Merriott as Courtroom Observer (uncredited)

Alanna Hamill Newton as Juror (uncredited)

Carmen Patterson as Courtroom Gallery / Protestor (uncredited)

Arnold John Popa III as Courtroom Observer / Reporter (uncredited)

Nicole A. Randall as Concert patron (uncredited)

Nokona Redus as Classmate (uncredited)

Ashley Richardson as Extra (uncredited)

Taylor Robirts as Protester (uncredited)

Samantha M Shaw as Protester (uncredited)

Isaac Slatton as Protester (uncredited)

Shawn C Smith as Concert Attendee (uncredited)

Kristina Strava as Concert Patron (uncredited)

Cameron Taylor as Lawyer Assistant (uncredited)

Stacey McBryde Valley as Extra (uncredited)

Mindy Van Kuren as Reporter (uncredited)

Terri Whitehurst as Concert Patron (uncredited)

Don E. Willis as Extra (uncredited)

Carey Scott as Richard Thawley