Barnard Hughes as Father Brown

Michael McGuire as Lieutenant Bellamy

George Hearn as Monsignor Kerrigan

Robert Schenkkan as Father Wembley

David Rasche as Jack Collins

Fred Gwynne as Judge Potter

Elizabeth Wilson as Mrs. Glidden

Kay Lenz as Carol Bain

Peter Maloney as Eli Clay

Saul Rubinek as Jerry Stone

Jeffrey DeMunn as Whitney Fowler

Donald Symington as Russell Heyman

Maureen Silliman as Beth Landau

Alice Drummond as Grace Barringer

Thomas Hill as Carl Barringer

Sydney Hibbert as Steeldrummer

David Ramsey as Auction Guest

Robin Mary Paris as Auction Guest #2

Gary Bayer as Mike

Sudie Bond as Annie

Mary Boylan as Mrs. Blount

William Duell as Park Keeper

Richard Hughes as Deputy Sheriff

David Patrick Kelly as Audience Member