Sunah Bilsted as Zoe Pendersen

Nathan Parsons as Justin Tyme

Sarah Paulson as Sarah Pendersen

Natasha Goss as Olivia

Jayme Ratzer as Barista

Seth Bailey as Priest

Darren Capozzi as Neighbor Sex Guy (voice)

Amanda Hendy as Coffee Shop Patron

Annie Hendy as Coffee Shop Patron

Robert Hubert as Coffee Shop Patron

Brett McKenzie as Coffee Shop Patron

Stacey Scowley as Neighbor Sex Girl (voice)

Susan Suite as Coffee Shop Patron