Andie MacDowell as Helen Kalahan

Cary Elwes as Ethan Belfrage

Frank Whaley as Aaron

Matt Dallas as Jake

Nicole Ansari-Cox as Kate Belfrage

Brian Cox as Reverend Kalahan

Clark Middleton as Seth

Emma Kantor as Sarah

Juliette Bennett as Erica

Nasry Malak as Moe

Crispian Belfrage as Brian Shepherd

Claudine Oriol as Marsha

J.W. Cortes as Cop

Laurence Covington as Cop #2

Mario D'Leon as Titus

Heidi Jo Markel as The investor

Elissa Middleton as Eve

Cygalle Dias as Bodega shopper

Alexandra Helgerson as Café couple

Jeffrey Dread as Café couple

John Michael Kelsey as Bus Driver

Antoine Ray as young Jake

Joe James as Hitman (uncredited)

Jess Weixler as Amy (uncredited)

John Shim as Masked Shooter