Lola Kirke as Joey

Breeda Wool as Rayna

Dale Soules as Ruthie

Ted Welch as Pete

Britne Oldford as Haley

Libby George as Gram

Bill Sage as Roy

Kyle Monaghan as Army Recruiter

Madeline Hindmarsh as Girl with Ice Cream

Nicole Dillon as Rayna's Friend #1

Dawn Santoriello as Rayna's Friend #2

Amanda K. Somma as Rayna's Friend #3

Charlotte Maltby as Kristen

Katie Kelly as Rayna's Friend #4

Nicole Lopez-Isa as Rayna's Friend #5

Sadie Butler as Sadie

Hannah Dillon as Hannah

David Koral as Chet

Adam Nortfors as Pete's Bandmate

Paul Hosey as Pete's Bandmate

Mike Munkatchy as Roy's Friend

Roy Brown as Roy's Friend

Scott Nadler as Roy's Friend

Sue Yurchak as Joey's Family Member

Mandy Kolensky as Joey's Family Member

Roxanne Stutzman as Joey's Family Member

Gwen Galasso as Joey's Family Member

Lily Williams as Joey's Family Member

Francesco Danza as Joey's Family Member

Krystian Bienkowski as Man in Bar

Ian Heath as Hairdresser

Chris Turcotte as Katana Chef

Leslie Healey as Katana Bartender

Chloë Levine as College Girl

Naomi Pandolfi as College Girl

Leah Kreitz as College Girl

Celia Au as College Girl

Chloe Piazza as College Girl

Alyx Weiss as College Girl

Cedar Landsman as College Girl

Janani Shankar as College Girl

Egypt Hemby as College Girl

Marina Hernandez as College Girl

Judd Shoval as Mr. Meyers

Ronne Kurlancheek as Hanukkah Party Guest

Ina Lubin as Hanukkah Party Guest

Wesley Parks as Hanukkah Party Guest

Sheldon Lubin as Hanukkah Party Guest

Virginia Davis as Hanukkah Party Guest

Lorraine Sokolowski as Hanukkah Party Guest

Pat Parks as Hanukkah Party Guest

Michael Rittenberg as Hanukkah Party Guest

Carmen Bolin as Hanukkah Party Guest

Susan Shoval as Hanukkah Party Guest

Ruthie O'Dell as Mary Sue

Amy Trynoski as Burlington Pedestrian

Rose Holcomb as Burlington Pedestrian

Caitlin Hill as Burlington Potluck Guest

Ray Young as Burlington Potluck Guest

Irit Reinheimer as Burlington Potluck Guest

Thomasin Thomo as Burlington Potluck Guest

Ezra Nepon as Burlington Potluck Guest

Bekah Saidman-Krauss as Burlington Potluck Guest

Laura Marie Thomson as Burlington Potluck Guest

Mike Hurwitz as Burlington Potluck Guest

Quehanna Spacht Weaver as Burlington Potluck Guest

Camille Cirurgiao as Burlington Potluck Guest

Erik Hussa-Lietz as Burlington Potluck Guest

Morgan Mihal as Burlington Potluck Guest

Micael Navarro Lopez as Burlington Potluck Guest

Erin Weaver as Burlington Potluck Musician

Elisabeth Weaver as Burlington Potluck Musician

Rick Zahn as Border Patrol

Megan Ellersick as Flamingo Diner Patron

Seana Warman as Flamingo Diner Patron