Jennifer Love Hewitt as Julie James

Freddie Prinze Jr. as Ray Bronson

Sarah Michelle Gellar as Helen Shivers

Ryan Phillippe as Barry Cox

Bridgette Wilson-Sampras as Elsa Shivers

Johnny Galecki as Max Neurick

Muse Watson as Benjamin Willis / Fisherman

Anne Heche as Melissa Egan

Stuart Greer as David Caporizo

Dan Albright as Sheriff

Rasool J'Han as Deb

J. Don Ferguson as MC

Deborah Hobart as Mrs. James

Mary McMillan as Mrs. Cox

Lynda Clark as Pageant Official

Shea Broom as Contestant #1

John Bennes as Old Man

Jennifer Bland as Contestant #2

William Neely as Hank

Jonathan Quint as David Egan

Richard Dale Miller as Band Member

Mary Neva Huff as Band Member

David Lee Hartman as Band Member

Patti D'Arbanville as Mrs. Shivers (uncredited)

David F. Maxwell as Fisherman at Bait Stand (uncredited)

Stephen McKenna as Delivery Guy (uncredited)