Karen Gillan as Rachel Milligan (segment 'Conventional')

Matthew Cardarople as Stu Mac 1 (segment 'Conventional')

James Ransone as Stu Mac 3 (segment 'Conventional')

Tracie Thoms as Tommy (segment 'Playing Dead')

Paul Telfer as Reggie (segment 'Playing Dead')

Megan Duffy as Melissa (segment 'Pinned')

Adi Shankar as Dex (segment 'Playing Dead')

Ryan Turek as Original Stu Mac (segment 'Conventional')

Diva Zappa as Audience Member (segment 'Last Laugh')

Justin Gordon as Evan (segment 'Pinned')

Mali Elfman as Lisa (segment 'Perfect')

Lara Sebastian as Emma (segment 'Conventional')

Amy Schloerb as Audience Member (segment 'Last Laugh')

Michael May as Stu Mac 2 (segment 'Conventional')

Trey Everett as Josh (segment 'Perfect')

Jake Varta as Joe (segment 'Playing Dead')

Andrew Furtado as Corbin (segment 'The Great Corbin')

Skylar Roberge as Grace (segment "Kill Them Mommy")

Kari Calhoun as Devon (segment "Kill Them Mommy")

Hayley Crisp as Dolores (segment "Kill Them Mommy")

Anthony Kirlew as Malcolm (segment "Prey")

Lucas Champagne as Ricky (segment "Prey")

Justin Mokayed as Seth (segment "Prey")

Sam Uehling as Jake (segment "Prey")

Josh Elliott as Man (segment "Whispers")