Adam Hicks as Toby (voice)

Dennis Haskins as Santa Claus

Angela Billman as Terra

Cait Collins as Mom

Brandon Baker as Accountant

Ben Easter as Bulldozer (voice)

Preston Lacy as Rusty (voice)

Kristian Day as Elf

Dave Juehring as Lieutenant Dan

Ben Kass as Stan

Thomas Ely Sage as Detective Fry

Joe Heath as Prison Dog (Voice)

Jesse Heisel as Elf

Ben Rollins as Commissioner Felix

Tom Garland as Bartender

Shawn McAninch as Santa's Attorney

Mike Schminke as Dewey

Jean Sheridan as Mrs. Claus

Joshua Heath as Biker

Patrick Bottaro as Max

Randy Miller as Biker 2

Paul Beckman as Elf

Scott Sanborn as Self

Wes Worthing as Crying Father

Greg Geffrard as Irwin

Richard Bowman as Biker in Kilt

Thomas Beecher as Melvin

Mike Kieler as Sarge (Voice)

Tyler Thirnbeck as Leroy

Gabe Thompson as Jim Keller

Tim Nash as Security Guard #2

Matt Sheridan as Dad

Kyle Schwarz as Security Guard

Judy Schwartz as Elf

Tammy Brice as Santa's Veterinarian

Harrison Pike as Reese

Eric Wozniak as Elf

Taylor Steimel as Elf

Sage Spiker as Oz

Alissa Sheldon as North Pole Announcer (Voice)

Gregga J. Johnn as Elf

Jodi Covington as Elf

Avery McBride as Will

Bill Adams as Elf

Zach Shladetzky as Elf

Benjamin Weeks as Elf

Kai Renatus as Elf