Vincent Price as James Addison Reavis

Ellen Drew as Sofia de Peralta-Reavis

Vladimir Sokoloff as Pepito Alvarez

Beulah Bondi as Loma Morales

Reed Hadley as John Griff

Robert Barrat as Judge Adams

Robin Short as Tom Lansing

Karen Kester as Sofia as a child

Margia Dean as Marquesa de Santella

Jonathan Hale as Governor

I. Stanford Jolley as Mr. Richardson

Tina Pine as Rita

Angelo Rossitto as Angie -- Gypsy

Edward Keane as Surveyor General Miller

Barbara Woodell as Mrs. Carrie Lansing

Fred Kohler Jr. as Demmings

Tris Coffin as McCleary

Gene Roth as Father Guardian

Ed East as Hank

Joseph J. Greene as Mr. Gunther

Abdullah Abbas as Indian (uncredited)

Walter Bacon as Townsman (uncredited)

Ray Beltram as Townsman (uncredited)

Eumenio Blanco as Gypsy (uncredited)

Phil Bloom as Townsman (uncredited)

Nick Borgani as Gypsy (uncredited)

Buck Bucko as Vigilante (uncredited)

Roy Bucko as Townsman (uncredited)

Wheaton Chambers as Brother Gregory (uncredited)

Noble 'Kid' Chissell as Townsman (uncredited)

Richard Cramer as Townsman Watching Reavis Return to Arizona (uncredited)

Russell Custer as Townsman (uncredited)

Tex Driscoll as Townsman (uncredited)

Sam Flint as Board Member - Department of Interior (uncredited)

Terry Frost as Morelle - Vigilante (uncredited)

Gil Frye as Griff's Associate (uncredited)

Elias Gamboa as Mexican Cemetery man (uncredited)

Rudy Germane as Officer (uncredited)

Kenneth Gibson as Party Guest (uncredited)

Pat Goldin as Diminutive Franciscan Monk (uncredited)

Herman Hack as Guard (uncredited)

Bobby Hale as Townsman (uncredited)

Stuart Hall as Party Guest (uncredited)

Stephen S. Harrison as Surveyor's Assistant (uncredited)

Al Haskell as Townsman (uncredited)

Jack Hendricks as Townsman (uncredited)

Tex Holden as Townsman (uncredited)

Stuart Holmes as Man in the Governor's Mansion (uncredited)

Kay Koury as Townswoman (uncredited)

Billy McCoy as Townsman (uncredited)

Mathew McCue as Townsman (uncredited)

Tom McDonough as Deputy (uncredited)

George Meader as Hank - Lansing's Father-in-Law (uncredited)

Jack Montgomery as Townsman (uncredited)

Lew Morphy as Vigilante Firing Signal Shot (uncredited)

Forbes Murray as Board Member - Department of Interior (uncredited)

Robert A. O'Neil as Brother Paul (uncredited)

Adolfo Ornelas as Mr. Martinez (uncredited)

Lee Phelps as Guest at Governor's Mansion (uncredited)

Joe Phillips as Deputy (uncredited)

Stanley Price as Mr. Reynolds (uncredited)

Buddy Roosevelt as Townsman (uncredited)

Frosty Royce as Deputy (uncredited)

Jeffrey Sayre as Townsman (uncredited)

Allen D. Sewall as Townsman (uncredited)

Sammy Shack as Townsman (uncredited)

Bert Stevens as Man at Governor's Mansion (uncredited)

Jack Tornek as Townsman (uncredited)

Blackie Whiteford as Townsman (uncredited)

Zacharias Yaconelli as Greco (uncredited)