Evan Peters as Jay Bahadur

Barkhad Abdi as Abdi

Melanie Griffith as Maria Bahadur

Al Pacino as Seymour Tolbin

Philip Ettinger as Alex

Russell Posner as Jared Bahadur

Kiana Madani as Tracy Ziconni

Maria Vos as Avril Benoît

Jojo Gonzalez as Jojo

Coral Peña as Katlyn

Jennifer Keane as Student

Alok Tewari as Kailash Bahadur

Robert Hobbs as Navy Admiral

Darron Meyer as Mitch Kelp

Aidan Whytock as Agent Brice

Armaan Haggio as Mohamed Farole Jr.

Sabrina Mohammed Hassan as Maryan

Mohamed Hakeemshady as Ancient Warrior (voice)

Pope Jerrod as Committee Member

Vere Tindale as CBSA Officer

Edward Gelbinovich as Clerk #1

Patrick Holden O'Neill as Angus (Clerk #2) (as Patrick O'Neill)

Lindsay Sullivan as Canadian Air Hostess

Mohamed Kalif Barre as Boyah

Matt Newman as Reporter

Sidow Farah Abdi as Colonel Omar

Mohamed Osmali Ibrahim as Garaad

Abdi Delgo as Colonel Delgo

Caprice Masinga as Jay's Driver

Minky Ndlovu as Ancient Warrior

Donat Balaj as Frank Reynolds

Mohamed Mohamud Hossein as Abdirizak - Town Sheriff

Amin Mohamed Osmaan as Abdul

Mark Turetsky as Additional Voices (voice)