Peter Dinklage as Reginald Jones

Juliette Lewis as Cut Throat Bill

Levon Hawke as Jack

Leslie Grace as Jimmie Sue

Gbenga Akinnagbe as Eustace

Esmé Creed-Miles as Lula

Andrew Schulz as Hector

Macon Blair as Malachi Deasy

Arliss Howard as Rev. Ephron Karlsson

James Hetfield as Simon Deasy

Ryan Robbins as Bailey Mayfield

Ned Dennehy as Baldy

David Midthunder as Black Mouth

Sophia Fabris as Little Girl

Guy Sprung as Caleb Parker

Derek Gilroy as Fatty

Chris Enright as Doctor

Teach Grant as Slim

Roger LeBlanc as Blondie

Brent Stait as Marvin Taylor

Caleb Ellsworth-Clark as John Taylor

Dusty Bews as Lynch Man #1

Kyle Thomson as Lynch Man #2

Rob Hay as Clerk

Tyson Martell as Native Man

David LeReaney as Ferryman

Diana-Marie Stolz as Ferryman's Wife

Luke Hubler-McManus as Kid 1

John Wills Martin as Sheriff Floyd Hapstack

Peter Bews as Town Drunk

Tommy Clarke as Deadman

Gavin Lester as Elliott

Allen Craig Hayes as Piano Player

C. Stephen Campbell as Lumber Man (uncredited)

Jeff Hanni as Saloon Patron (uncredited)