Dylan Sprouse as Lucas Ward

Kent Osborne as Mr. Butler

Rae Gray as Becca Vaughn

Randall Park as Mr. Sheldon

Brooke Dillman as Valerie Lohman

Matthew J. Evans as Alex

Mark Kelly as Detective Speck

Mitchell Edwards as Chris

Victoria Zeutzius as Paige

Robert Longstreet as Paul Garrett

Rowan Smyth as Young Lucas

Jeanette Maus as Nancy

Alycia Delmore as Rachel Butler