Robert De Niro as Frank Sheeran

Al Pacino as Jimmy Hoffa

Joe Pesci as Russell Bufalino

Harvey Keitel as Angelo Bruno

Ray Romano as Bill Bufalino

Bobby Cannavale as Skinny Razor

Anna Paquin as Older Peggy Sheeran

Stephen Graham as Anthony "Tony Pro" Provenzano

Stephanie Kurtzuba as Irene Sheeran

Jack Huston as Robert Kennedy / RFK

Kathrine Narducci as Carrie Bufalino

Jesse Plemons as Chuckie O'Brien

Domenick Lombardozzi as Fat Tony Salerno

Paul Herman as Whispers DiTullio

Gary Basaraba as Frank "Fitz" Fitzsimmons

Marin Ireland as Older Dolores Sheeran

Lucy Gallina as Young Peggy Sheeran

Jonathan Morris as Assisted Living Priest

Dascha Polanco as Nurse

Welker White as Josephine "Jo" Hoffa

Louis Cancelmi as Sally Bugs

Bo Dietl as Joe Glimco

Sebastian Maniscalco as Crazy Joe Gallo

Aleksa Palladino as Mary Sheeran

Steven Van Zandt as Jerry Vale

Jim Norton as Don Rickles

Daniel H. Jenkins as E. Howard "Big Ears" Hunt

Billy Smith as FBI Agent #1

Kevin O'Rourke as John McCullough

Action Bronson as Casket Salesman

Glenn Cunningham as Investigator

Paul Ben-Victor as Jake Gottlieb

Patrick Gallo as Anthony "Tony Jack" Giacalone

James Martin as Mother of Sorrows Priest

Jake Hoffman as Allen Dorfman

Barry Primus as Ewing King

Danny A. Abeckaser as Deadbeat

Anthony J. Gallo as Food Fair Manager

J.C. MacKenzie as Prosecutor Jim Neal

Joseph Bono as Frank Sindone

Jamil Antonio Stefan as Phil Testa

Louis Vanaria as Dave Ferrie

Craig Vincent as Ed Partin

John Polce as Joe Colombo

Joseph Riccobene as Jimmy "The Weasel" Fratianno

Vinny Vella as Meat Company Yard Manager

Thomas E. Sullivan as Warren Swanson

John Cenatiempo as Anthony "Tony 3 Fingers" Castellito

Robert Mladinich as Anastasia Bodyguard

Rich Reilly as Phil The Bartender

Robert Funaro as Johnny - Friendly Lounge

Tess Price as Young Maryanne Sheeran

Jennifer Mudge as Older Maryanne Sheeran

India Ennenga as Young Dolores

Jordyn DiNatale as Young Connie Sheeran

Kate Arrington as Older Connie Sheeran

Bernie Martin as Teamster

Philip Suriano as Silver Shop Owner

Tony Suriano as Silver Shop Owner's Son

Jason A. Iannacone as German Prisoner #1

Michael C. Brennan as German Prisoner #2

James P. Harkins as John The Redhead

Al Linea as Sam "Momo" Giancana

Garry Pastore as Albert Anastasia

Frank Pietrangolare as Bartender - Friendly Lounge

Frank Aquilino as Friendly Lounge Guy "Butchie"

Johnny T. Sollitto as Friendly Lounge Patron

Patrick Murney as Peggy's Godfather

Samantha Soule as Peggy's Godmother

Richard V. Licata as Judge - Frank's First Trial

Vito Picone as Villa Roma Manager

Larry Mazza as Anastasia's Hitman #1

Craig DiFrancia as Anastasia's Hitman #2

Ira Drukier as Motel Manager

Jon Bruno as Russell's Bodyguard

Paul Borghese as Mobster #1 - Curtain Shop

Steven Maglio as Mobster #2 - Curtain Shop / Copa Guest #1

James Licata as Mobster #3 - Curtain Shop

Veronica Alicino as Curtain Shop Staff #1

Mike Massimino as Curtain Shop Staff #2

James Ciccone as Anastasia Mobster in Car #1

Ron Castellano as Anastasia Mobster in Car #2

Marco Greco as Grocer

Meghan Rafferty as Bill Bufalino's Wife

Aldo Sergi as Aldo

James Lorinz as Hoffa Rally Teamster #1

Jeffrey Paul as Hoffa Rally Teamster #2

Robert C. Kirk as Hoffa Rally Teamster #3

Vince Maritato as Bathhouse Teamster

Lawrence Smith as Louis

Rebecca Faulkenberry as Barbara Hoffa

Ken Wulf Clark as James P. Hoffa

John Rue as Senator McClellan

Steve Routman as Hoffa Attorney - George Fitzgerald

Fernando Vera as Castellito's Driver

Peter Claymore as Tough Teamster - Hoffa's Office

Charles DelGatto as Phil - Milestone Hauling

Michael Gongora as Cuban Worker

Eugene Bunge as Joseph Kennedy

Matthew F. O'Connor as Pro Rally Teamster #1

Cliff Moylan as Pro Rally Teamster #2

Vincenzo DelRiccio as Pro Rally Teamster #3

Steve Beauchamp as Pro Rally Teamster #4

Alfred Sauchelli, Jr. as Trucking Company Owner

Joe Giorgio as Local 326 Truck Driver

Diana Agostini as Ice Cream Shop Patron #1

Lauren Aparicio as Ice Cream Shop Patron #2

Kelley Rae O'Donnell as Ice Cream Shop Staff #1

John Garrett Greer as Ice Cream Shop Staff #2

Jack Caruso as Swanson's Booking Detective

John Scurti as Bertram B. Beveridge

Thomas J. Jenkins as Nashville Court Clerk

Steve Witting as Judge William Miller

Luke Smith as Reporter

Brent Langdon as Judge Frank Wilson

James D. Forsha as Tony Pro FBI Agent #1

Giacomino J. Matra as Tony Pro Guy #1

Paul Pearlman as Tony Pro Guy #2

Frank L. Messina as Tony Pro Guy #3

Cilda Shaur as Colombo's Wife

Dominick LaRuffa Jr. as Colombo's Son #1

Erick Zamora as Colombo's Son #2

Joe Caniano as Copa Guest #2

Lou Martini Jr. as Copa Guest #3

Michael Bottari as Copa Guest #4

John Bianco as Copa Guest #5

Margaret Anne Florence as Gallo's Wife Sina

Siena Marino as Gallo's Daughter Lisa

Lori Arkin as Gallo's Sister Carmella Fiorello

Nicholas Chrysan as Pete The Greek

Samantha Coppola as Pete The Greek's Girlfriend

Logan Crawford as Reporter at Prison

Jeff DeHart as President Nixon

Mark Fairchild as Attorney General Mitchell

Blaise Corrigan as Dave Johnson

Jill Brown as Dave Johnson's Wife

Tim Neff as Little Fitz

Matt Walton as TV Host / Moderator

Peter Jay Fernandez as NAACP President Cecil Moore

Stephen Mailer as District Attorney Emmett Fitzpatrick

Gino Cafarelli as Mayor Frank Rizzo

Robin Kerbis as Angelo Bruno's Wife

Lucia Giannetta as Tony Pro's Wife

Michael Romeo Ruocco as Casino Photographer

Amanda Kloots as Golddigger Dancer

Anne Horak as Golddigger Dancer

Brittany Bigelow as Golddigger Dancer

Vanessa Mitchell as Golddigger Dancer

Madison Eastman as Golddigger Dancer

Purdie Baumann as Golddigger Dancer

Jesse Wildman as Golddigger Dancer

Nina Lafarga as Golddigger Dancer

Neil Posner as Jerry Vale Band

Michael Leviton as Jerry Vale Band

Bridget Barkan as Jerry Vale Band

Andrea Weinzierl as Jerry Vale Band

Richard V. Pagano as Jerry Vale Band

Nicholas Wight as Jerry Vale Band

Clark Carmichael as Pilot

Joseph Russo as Bruno Denzetta

Jeremy Luke as Marco Rossi

Barbara Eyland as Guest Dancing at Casino #1

Tracy J. Everitt as Guest Dancing at Casino #2

Saint Marino as Wedding Wise Guy #1

Mario Corry as Wedding Wise Guy #2

Johnny Potenza as Wedding Wise Guy #3

Joe Passaro as Wedding Wise Guy #4

Patrick Borriello as Wedding Wise Guy #5

Alfred Nittoli as Inmate Alfredo

David Aaron Baker as Assistant US Attorney

Stanley Burns as Colonoscopy Doctor

Bill Timoney as Prosecutor - Frank's 2nd Trial

Thomas J. McDonald as Deputy Clerk - Frank's 2nd Trial

Virl Andrick as Judge - Frank's 2nd Trial

Ernest L. Sanders Jr. as Frank's Orderly

Bill McHugh as Funeral Priest

Kevin Kane as FBI Agent #2

Amelia Brain as Sales Girl at Crypt

Craig 'Radio Man' Castaldo as Man in Wheelchair

Michael Iacono as Bowler (uncredited)

Dean Ciallella as Italian Rally Supporter (uncredited)

Tommy Bayiokos as Truck Driver (uncredited)

Michael Cullum as Juror (uncredited)

Rick Bolander as Lewisburg Guard (uncredited)

Shade Rupe as Teamster (uncredited)

Ian Zelbo as Brother in Ice Cream Parlor (uncredited)

Jacqueline Kennedy as Self (archive footage)(uncredited)

John F. Kennedy as Self (archive footage)(uncredited)

Leonard Zimmerman as Supervisor - Cadillac Linen (uncredited)