Lucy Hale as Lily Weil

Kathryn Prescott as Chloe Daniels

Alexandra Shipp as Amelia Bergbaum-Goldstein

Awkwafina as Rebecca Voller

Alex Wolff as Noah

Jerry MacKinnon as Sam

Michaela Watkins as Jill Weil

Austin Abrams as James Weil

Austin Butler as Thomas Daniels

Brooke Smith as Lorraine Daniels

Ronen Rubinstein as Mike

Satya Bhabha as Immanuel Bemis

Sydney Lucas as Olivia Weil

Nora Dunn as Rosa

Ian Gomez as Jerry

Colton Dunn as Officer Higgins

Jack McBrayer as Guy

Sasha Spielberg as Carrie

D.C. Pierson as Biff

Claudia Doumit as Jessica

Matt Corboy as Officer Clark

Artemis Pebdani as Sapphire

Esther Povitsky as Alicia

Stony Blyden as Stony

Gracie Watrous as Rose

Alana Baer as Anna

Sabina Friedman-Seitz as Katie B

Hayden Tweedie as Goalie

Chelsea O'Toole as Shot Girl

Stephon Fuller as Soccer Ref

Dana Williams as Crooner

Easton Alexeyev as Soccer Player (uncredited)

David S. Robinson Hicks as High School Student (uncredited)

Brooke Markham as Goth Girl