Preston Foster as John Kelley

Barbara Britton as Cynthy Waters

John Ireland as Bob Ford

Reed Hadley as Jesse James

J. Edward Bromberg as Harry Kane

Victor Kilian as Soapy

Tom Tyler as Frank James

Tommy Noonan as Charles Ford

Eddie Dunn as Joe, Silver King Bartender

Margia Dean as Saloon Singer

Byron Foulger as Silver King Room Clerk

Jeni Le Gon as Veronica, Cynthy's Maid

Barbara Woodell as Mrs. Zee James

Phillip Pine as Man in Saloon

Robin Short as Troubadour

Willie Bloom as Waiter (uncredited)

Gene Collins as Young Gunslinger (uncredited)

Albert Glasser as Musician (uncredited)

Frank Hagney as Livery Stableman (uncredited)

George Huggins as Barfly (uncredited)

Mickey Ireland as Gang Member (uncredited)

Ray Jones as Barfly (uncredited)

Jack Low as Barfly (uncredited)

Robert Malcolm as Marshal Craig (uncredited)

Mathew McCue as Barfly (uncredited)

George Morrell as Play Spectator (uncredited)

Stanley Price as Bank Cashier (uncredited)

Jack Richardson as St. Joseph Saloon Bartender (uncredited)

Britt Wood as Play Spectator (uncredited)

Pete Kellett as Townsman (uncredited)