Van Heflin as Lee Hackett

Tab Hunter as Ed Hackett

Kathryn Grant as Cecily "Clee" Chouard

James Darren as Davy Hackett

Mickey Shaughnessy as Deputy Sheriff Will Motely

Robert F. Simon as Sheriff Harry Brill

Edward Platt as Purcell Avery

Ray Teal as Jensen Sieverts

Paul Birch as Bob Selkirk

Michael Granger as Curly

Will Wright as Judge

Dorothy Adams as Martha Stotheby

Harry Antrim as Dr. Thomas Butler

Bert Convy as Paul Chouard

Paul E. Burns as Cook

Everett Glass as Rev. Arthur Stotheby

Herman Hack as Townsman (uncredited)