Hannah Cagwin as Self - JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee

Aeona Cruz as Self - JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee

Liv Bagley as Self - JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee

Shylee Sagle as Self - JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee

Danika Toolson as Self - JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee

Emma Winslow as Self - JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee

Elle Walker as Self - JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee

Kaydence Lucero as Self - JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee

Nicole Hamilton as Self - JonBenet Ramsey Auditionee / JonBenet Ramsey Dance Double

Kit Thompson as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Amy Dowd as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Teresa Cocas as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Stephanie Federico as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Tamara Hutchins as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Deb Hultgren as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Ronda Belser as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Dorinda Dercar as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Carolyn Strauss as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Marian Rothschild as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Aspen Rader as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Suzanne Yazzie as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Kaye Taavialma as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Jacqui Pugh as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Laura Lee as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Kristina Jones as Self - Patsy Ramsey Auditionee

Hack Hyland as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Gary Foster as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Ed Hickok as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Gary J. Neuger as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Chuck Fiorella as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Robert Toomey as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Mark Taylor as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Jay Benedict Brown as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Chris Mueser as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Paul Crumby as Self - John Ramsey Auditionee

Jerry Cortese as Self - Officer French / John Ramsey Auditionee

J. Michael Sterling as Self - Officer Veitch / John Ramsey Auditionee

Ryan Haskell as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Taylor Hollenback as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Jase Wiedeman as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Tre Penna as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Riley Hastings as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Sean Legg as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Luca Rodriguez as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Joe Brienza as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Gavin White as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Noah Isakson as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

Robby Hanbery as Self - Burke Ramsey Auditionee

William Tidwell as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

Blake Curton as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

Rj Clay as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

John Bronson as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

Carlos Martinez as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

Michael Kennedy as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

Timothy Ackerman as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

Casey Lloyd as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

Mark Canjar as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

Dan Davidson as Self - Police Chief Auditionee

Dale Strom as Self - Reporter / Police Chief Auditionee

John Chilson as Self - Santa Claus Auditionee

Johnny Claus as Self - Santa Claus Auditionee

Jim Beck as Self - Santa Claus Auditionee

Randy Schriever as Self - Santa Claus Auditionee

James Lewis as Self - Santa Claus Auditionee

Dixon White as Self - John Mark Karr Auditionee

Joe Bocian as Self - John Mark Karr Auditionee

Steven Scott as Self - John Mark Karr Auditionee

Rand Moritzky as Coroner

Gary Woods as Funeral Director

Lynne Jordan as Psychologist