Elliot Page as Lucy

Kate Mara as Mercy

Amy Seimetz as Martha

Charlie Shotwell as Benjamin

Elias Koteas as Simon

Tonya Pinkins as Agatha

Brian Geraghty as Weldon

Beau Knapp as Toby

Jake Robinson as Ian

Denise Dal Vera as Alice

Buz Davis as Morris

Jordan Trovillion as Katlin

Bishop Stevens as Paul

Lisa DeRoberts as Toni

Mac Blais as Billy

Kevin Crowley as Ernie

Bryant Bentley as Missouri Reporter

Dann Fink as Announcer (voice)

Matt Walton as Announcer (voice)

William C. Ingram as Protestor (uncredited)

Bret Aaron Knower as Cop/ Bar Patron

John E. Brownlee as Police Lieutenant (uncredited)