Bill Pullman as Lefty Brown

Peter Fonda as Edward Johnson

Kathy Baker as Laura Johnson

Jim Caviezel as Jimmy Bierce

Tommy Flanagan as Tom Harrah

Diego Josef as Jeremiah

Joseph Lee Anderson as Oak

Michael Spears as Biscuit

Dillinger Steele as Doc

Brian Henningsen as Sampson

Emily Jones as Red Blake

Lexi Anastasia as Townsperson

Joe Anderson as Frank

Josiah Burdick as Cowboy / Townsperson

Duel Farnes as Virgil

Tyson Gerhardt as Irish William

Adam O'Byrne as Crobley

Lewis Pullman as Billy Kitchen

Stephen Alan Seder as Noah Debow

Travis W Bruyer as Cowboy (uncredited)

Scott McCauley as Townsperson (uncredited)

Karlee Jane as Townsperson (uncredited)

Mathieu Szymkowiak as Jimmy Bierce