Anna Kendrick as Noelle Kringle

Bill Hader as Nick Kringle

Kingsley Ben-Adir as Jake Hapman

Billy Eichner as Gabriel Kringle

Julie Hagerty as Mrs. Kringle

Shirley MacLaine as Elf Polly

Diana Maria Riva as Helen Rojas

Maceo Smedley as Alex

Jason Antoon as Omar

Michael Gross as Elder Elf Abe

Billy Griffith as Elder Elf Billy

Anthony Konechny as Elf Ted

Aliza Vellani as Tech Elf Jojo

Amitai Marmorstein as Tech Elf Robrob

Ron Funches as Elf Mortimer

Chelah Horsdal as Shelley Sussman

Andy Nez as Mall Santa

Anna Van Hooft as Elf Mary

Burgess Jenkins as Dan

Owen Vaccaro as Young Nick

Jay Brazeau as Santa

Taylor Bedford as Teenage Noelle

Oakley Bull as Young Noelle

William Valenzuela as Matt Bautista (uncredited)

Clyde Lawrence as Elf Band #1

Gracie Lawrence as Elf Carol