Michael Parks as Pastor Abin Cooper

John Goodman as Joseph Keenan

Melissa Leo as Sara

Michael Angarano as Travis

Kyle Gallner as Jarod

Nicholas Braun as Billy-Ray

Kerry Bishé as Cheyenne

Stephen Root as Sherrif Wynan

Matt Jones as Deputy Pete

Kevin Alejandro as Harry, the Tactical Agent

Ralph Garman as Caleb

Anna Gunn as Travis' Mother

Kevin Pollak as ASAC Brooks

Betty Aberlin as Abigail

Jennifer Schwalbach Smith as Esther

Patrick Fischler as Agent Hammond

Damian Young as Agent Carol

David Marciano as Agent Eccles

Kaylee DeFer as Dana

Ronnie Connell as Randy

Alexa Nikolas as Jesse

Cooper Thornton as Plastic Wrap Man

James Parks as Mordechai

Haley Ramm as Maggie

Elizabeth Tripp as Melanie

Molly Livingston as Fiona May

John Lacy as Travis' Father

Catherine McCord as News Reporter

Deborah Aquila as Mrs. Vasquez

Joey Figueroa as Route 9 Friend

Rose Colasanti as Believer

Carryl Lynn as Believer

Alyssa Petersen as Believer

Bill Cleavelin as Believer

Sadey Paige Nifong as Believer

Scott Nifong as Believer

Gary Sievers as Believer

Marc Blucas as ATF Sniper

Molly Hagan as Janet Keenan

Kevin Smith as Prisoner (voice)