Julia Roberts as Holly Burns

Lucas Hedges as Ben Burns

Courtney B. Vance as Mr. Beeby

Kathryn Newton as Ivy Burns

Rachel Bay Jones as Beth Conyers

David Zaldivar as Spencer 'Spider' Webbs

Alexandra Park as Cara K.

Michael Esper as Clayton

Tim Guinee as Phil

Myra Lucretia Taylor as Sally

Kristin Griffith as Mrs. Crane

Jack Davidson as Dr. Crane

Mia Fowler as Lacey Beeby

Jakari Fraser as Liam Burns-Beeby

Cameron Scott Roberts as James Lamson

Jeff Auer as Maggie's Dad

Henry Stram as Mr. Richman

Bill Buell as Dairy Farmer

Sandra Caldwell as Customer

Nathalie Carvalho as Lay Reader

Emily Cass McDonnell as Bobette Parker

Marquise Vilson as Leon B.

Melissa van der Schyff as Robin Striem

Jocelyn Bioh as Nicole Hill

Gamze Ceylan as Pharmacist

Michelle Hedges as Carole H.

Karen Willock as Karen W.

Leon Addison Brown as Willie G.

Bevan Thomas as Gwenyth B.

Crystal Bock as Jessie

Rosalie Tenseth as Officer Reidy

Michael David Baldwin as Officer Wheeler

Ian Stark as Clayton's 2nd

Anna Lee Warren as Church Choir

Avery Soto as Church Choir

Vincenzo James Harty as Church Choir

Olivia Etchings as Church Choir

Kameron S. Holder as Church Choir

Daniella Guigliano as Church Choir

Julien Tornelli as Church Choir

Elwaldo Baptiste as Churchgoer (uncredited)

Rich Campbell as Recovering Addict (uncredited)

John Cashin as Doppelgänger (uncredited)

Teddy Cañez as Officer Thomas (uncredited)

Rosemary Howard as Christmas Service Congregant (uncredited)

Samantha Kelly as Window Shopper (uncredited)

Eduardo Muniz as Mexican Thug (uncredited)

Leo Orgil as Nativity Scene Child (uncredited)

Sammy Peralta as Mexican Thug (uncredited)

Shaun Rey as Mexican Thug (uncredited)

Jessica VanOss as Mall Shopper (uncredited)

Frankie Verroca as Crackhead Junkie (uncredited)