Ethan Hawke as Sheriff Pat Garrett

Dane DeHaan as Billy 'The Kid' Bonney

Jake Schur as Rio Cutler

Leila George as Sara Cutler

Adam Baldwin as Bob Orlinger

Chris Pratt as Grant Cutler

Charlie Chappell as Billy Wilson

Clint Obenchain as Tom Pickett

Chris Bylsma as Charlie Bowdre

Chad Dashnaw as Dave Rudabaugh

Ben Dickey as Jim East

Tait Fletcher as Bill Cutler

Hawk D'Onofrio as Oran Moler

Diana Navarrete as Manuela

Samantha Zajarias as Paulita Maxwell

Vincent D'Onofrio as Sheriff Romero

David Devereaux as First Reporter

Rachel Singer as Cricket (Whore)

Jenny Gabrielle as Mirabel

Howard Ferguson Jr. as Tall Man

Santo Militello as Butcher

Keith Jardine as Paul Jankowski

Dillon D. Jordan as Second Guard

Joseph Santos as James Bell

Leslie Fleming-Mitchell as Bank Clerk

Joe Berryman as Older Doctor

Douglas Bennett as Gauss

Efrain Villa as Mexican Worker

Stafford Douglas as John Poe

Merritt C. Glover as Singing Painted Lady

MorningStar Angeline as Young Whore

Jacob Browne as Bartender

David Christian Welborn as Father

Georgia Kirshenbaum as Stagecoach Daughter

Cameron Thurlow as Stagecoach Son

Carlos Amorin as Young Mob Leader

Thomas Wingate as T. Wingate

Danielle Haynes as Mother

Rose Cordova as Mother Maxwell (uncredited)

Rachel de la Torre as Hispanic School Teacher (uncredited)

Yvette Fazio-Delaney as Wash lady (uncredited)

Shannon Henderson Herrera as Brothel Woman #2 (uncredited)

David Hight as Santa Fe Policeman (uncredited)

Sarah Murrey as Townsperson (uncredited)

J. Nathan Simmons as Townsperson (uncredited)

Rip Lowe as

Christian Dalton as Townsman (uncredited)