Lukas Haas as Frankie Scarlatti

Len Cariou as Phil Terragarossa

Alex Rocco as Angelo 'Al' Scarlatti

Katherine Helmond as Amanda

Jason Presson as Geno Scarlatti

Renata Vanni as Mama Assunta

Angelo Bertolini as Papa Charlie

Joelle Jacobi as Melissa Anne Montgomery

Jared Rushton as Donald

Gregory Levinson as Louie

Lucy Lee Flippin as Grace La Della

Tom Bower as Sheriff Saunders

Jack Andreozzi as Tony

Sydney Lassick as Mr. Lowry

Rita Zohar as Mrs. Agnes Cilak

Hal Bokar as Mr. Cilak

Rose Weaver as Matty Williams

Henry Harris as Harold Williams

Emily Tracy as Marianna

Karen Powell as Anne Montgomery/ Lady in White

Lisa Taylor as Mary Ellen

Bruce Kirby as Cabbie

Jack Holland as Father Brennan

Daniel Rojo as Reporter

Gregory L. Everage as Cameraman

Frank LaLoggia as Frank Scarlatti (adult) (uncredited)