John Legend as Jesus Christ

Sara Bareilles as Mary Magdalene

Brandon Victor Dixon as Judas Iscariot

Alice Cooper as King Herod

Norm Lewis as Caiaphas

Ben Daniels as Pontius Pilate

Jason Tam as Peter

Jin Ha as Annas

Erik Grönwall as Simon Zealotes

Melody Betts as Ensemble

Felicia Boswell as Ensemble

Abby Corrigan as Ensemble

Micaela Diamond as Ensemble

Rory Donovan as Ensemble

Christine Dwyer as Ensemble

Mike Evariste as Ensemble

F. Michael Haynie as Ensemble

Charissa Hogeland as Ensemble

Bre Jackson as Ensemble

Mykal Kilgore as Ensemble

Billy Lewis Jr. as Ensemble

Justin Gregory Lopez as Ensemble

Angel Lozada as Ensemble

Vincent Oddo as Ensemble

Kyle Taylor Parker as Ensemble

Joel Perez as Ensemble

Jonah Platt as Ensemble

Conor Ryan as Ensemble

Christina Sajous as Ensemble

Justin Sargent as Ensemble

Heath Saunders as Ensemble

Joey Taranto as Ensemble

Syndee Winters as Ensemble

Lauren Zakrin as Ensemble

Chloe Davis as Dancer

Timothy Andrew Edwards as Dancer

Shelby Finnie as Dancer

Bahiyah Hibah as Dancer

Juel D. Lane as Dancer

Terk Lewis as Dancer

Mayte Natalio as Dancer

Sarah Parker as Dancer

Willie Smith III as Dancer

Maleek Washington as Dancer