Eric Freeman as Ricky Caldwell

James Newman as Dr. Henry Bloom

Elizabeth Kaitan as Jennifer

Jean Miller as Mother Superior

Darrel Guilbeau as Ricky at 15

Brian Michael Henley as Ricky at 10

Corrine Gelfan as The Rosenbergs

Michael Combatti as The Rosenbergs

Ken Weichert as Chip

Ron Moriarty as Detective

Frank Novak as Loan Shark

Randall Boffman as Eddie

Joanne White as Paula

Lenny Rose as Loser

Nadya Wynd as Sister Mary

Kenneth McCabe as Rent-A-Cop

J. Aubrey Island as Orderly

Randy Post as Loudmouth in Theater

Kent Koppase as Cop #1

Stephanie Babbit as Little Girl on Bicycle

Michael Marloe as Cop #2

Traci Odom as Nun on Street

Jennie Webb as Nun on Street

Larry Kelman as Cop #3 / Paramedic

Janice Carlberg as Teen Lover at Orphanage

Jher Turner as Teen Lover at Orphanage

Jill K. Allen as Mrs. Rosenberg's Friend

Delia Lombardo as Roxanne

Stephen Parks as Photographer

O.J. Ackson as Officer Jackson

Fred Griggs as Moviegoer

Sally Bedding as Moviegoer

Spud Plugman as Moviegoer

Richard Levine as Moviegoer

Dianne C. Weed as Moviegoer

Amy Hamovitz as Moviegoer

John Fitzgibbons as Kid at Play

Scottie Simpfender as Kid at Play

Erin Darini as Kid at Play

Lara Davini as Kid at Play

Brian Davini as Kid at Play

Erika Lundquist as Saleslady

Harvey Genkins as Salvation Santa

Samurai Retz as Self

Lilyan Chauvin as Mother Superior (archive footage)

Gilmer McCormick as Sister Margaret (archive footage)

Toni Nero as Pamela (archive footage)

Robert Brian Wilson as Billy at 18 (archive footage)

Britt Leach as Mr. Simms (archive footage)

Nancy Borgenicht as Mrs. Randall (archive footage)

H.E.D. Redford as Capt. Richards (archive footage)

Linnea Quigley as Denise (archive footage)

Randy Stumpf as Andy (archive footage)

Tara Buckman as Mother (archive footage)

Geoff Hansen as Father (archive footage)

Charles Dierkop as Killer Santa (archive footage)

A. Madeline Smith as Sister Ellen (archive footage)

Max Robinson as Officer Barnes (archive footage)

Vinc Massa as Young Boy Sledding (archive footage)

John Michael Alvarez as Young Boy Sledding (archive footage)

John Bishop as Older Boy Sledding (archive footage)

Richard C. Terry as Older Boy Sledding (archive footage)

Richard D. Clark as Officer Miller (archive footage)

Tip Boxell as Officer Murphy (archive footage)

Don Shanks as Santa Climbing in Window (archive footage)

Angela Montoya as Girl on Santa's Lap (archive footage)

Molly Cameron as Girl's Mother (archive footage)

Jayne Luke as Other Mother (archive footage)

Joan Forster as Other Mother (archive footage)

Betsy Nagel as Other Mother (archive footage)

Spencer Ashby as Santa at Orphanage (archive footage)

Alex Burton as Ricky at 14 (archive footage)

Max Broadhead as Ricky at 4 (archive footage)

Spencer Alston as Child at Orphanage (archive footage)

Kristi Ballard as Child at Orphanage (archive footage)

Jacob Peterson as Child at Orphanage (archive footage)

Jonathan Wilde as Child at Orphanage (archive footage)

Susie Massa as Child at Orphanage (archive footage)