Mary Martin as Peter Pan

Cyril Ritchard as Mr. Darling / Captain Hook

Lynn Fontanne as Narrator

Maureen Bailey as Wendy / Jane

Margalo Gillmore as Mrs. Darling

Sondra Lee as Tiger Lily

Joe E. Marks as Smee

Norman Shelly as Nana / Crocodile

Joey Trent as John

Kent Fletcher as Michael

Jacqueline Mayro as Liza

Edmund Gaynes as Slightly

Bill Snowden as Curly

Carson Woods as Nibs

Benedict Herrman as First Twin

Luke Halpin as Second Twin

David Komoroff as Tootles

Richard Wyatt as Lion

Joan Tewkesbury as Ostrich

Peggy Maurer as Wendy Grown-up

John Holland as Black Bill

Robert Vanselow as Starkey

Richard Winter as Cecco

George Zima as Kangaroo

Frank Lindsay as Pirate

Frank Marasco as Pirate

Arthur Partington as Pirate

Jim Sisco as Pirate

Kirby Smith as Pirate

John Smolko as Pirate

Arthur Tookoian as Pirate

James B. Welch as Pirate

Linda Dangcil as Indian

George Lake as Indian

Lisa Lang as Indian

Diki Lerner as Indian

Annabelle Lyon as Indian

Robert Piper as Indian

Suzanne Rivera as Indian

Anne Wallace as Indian

Jerry Johnson as Pirate (uncredited)