Steve Diasparra as Randy Bucks

Elissa Dowling as Woman in Flashback

Mark Polonia as Station Manager

Jeff Kirkendall as Interviewee - Killers Neighbor

Kyle Rappaport as Terry (archive footage)

Maria Davis as Interviewee - Angry Woman

Jamie Morgan as Sam

Mariah Joyce as Jane

Nicholas Olsen as A.J.

Christopher Beacom as Thug

James Carolus as Camp Blood Killer

Greta Volkova as Ginny (archive footage)

Melissa Heflin as Anne (archive footage)

Wyatt Wood as Drake (archive footage)

Titus Himmelberger as Bishop (archive footage)

Tim Hatch as Interviewee - Concerned Citizen

Tina Krause as Nancy (archive footage)