Tom Arnold as Nick

Candace Cameron Bure as Holly

Christopher Wiehl as Peter

Barbara Niven as Ginny

Matt Walton as Ben Richards

Allan F. Nicholls as Earl

Kaily Smith Westbrook as Brenda

Heather Remick as Della

Bruce Bouchard as Mr. Covell

Richard Waterhouse as Mr. Jennings

Taylor Ampatiellos as Willy

Lillian Pritchard as Young Holly

Ari Larson as Young Peter

Parma as Nick's Dog

Gary Boyles as Office worker (uncredited)

Dave Kulvete as Elf waiter (uncredited)

Emily George Lyons as Willy's Mom (uncredited)

R.W. Martin as Townsperson (uncredited)