Neil Patrick Harris as William Coit

Bonnie Bedelia as Jill Coit

Meredith Salenger as Robin Coit

Terry Kiser as Uncle Paul

Jon Pennell as Seth Coit

Gary Graham as Mike Backus

Ernie Lively as Gerry Boggs

Arthur Taxier as Rev. Charles Coit

Steven Williams as Det. Sexton

Michael MacRae as Carl Steely

Bruce Gray as Ed Holm

Christine Avila as Aunt Alma