Jamey Sheridan as Harry Sweeney

Steve Buscemi as Thomas Kelley

Mariann Mayberry as Judy Rheems

Aidan Quinn as Prof. Porter

John Savage as Peter Rheems

Campbell Scott as David Kagan

Titus Welliver as Gebhardt

Karen Young as Muriel

Jayne Atkinson as Kelley's Wife

Bill Sage as Pauley

Emily Donahoe as Kelley's Daughter

Asher Grodman as Bobby Sweeney

Andrew Dolan as Sam

Rutanya Alda as Mrs. Schroeder

Derrick Jones as Bat Patron (uncredited)