Jacob Wysocki as Terri

John C. Reilly as Mr. Fitzgerald

Creed Bratton as Uncle James

Olivia Crocicchia as Heather Miles

Bridger Zadina as Chad

Mary Anne McGarry as Ms Hamish

Justin Prentice as Dirty Jack

Jenna Gavigan as Samantha Goode

Curtiss Frisle as Sex Ed

Tara Karsian as Mrs. Davidson

Diane Salinger as Mrs. Vick

Jessica D. Stone as Rachel

Jamie Lee Redmon as Rachel

Tim Heidecker as Mr. Flemisch

Robert Towers as Priest

Melanie Abramoff as Amy

Jeffrey Noah Silcock as Donny Washburn

Lisa Hoover as Waitress

Josh Perry as Marcus Bloom (as Josh 'The Ponceman' Perry)

Eddie Pepitone as Joe Hollywood