Minka Kelly as Coretta 'Cara' Rudland

Chad Michael Murray as Brett Beauchamps

Andie MacDowell as Lovie Rudland

Makenzie Vega as Toy

Donna Biscoe as Flo

Donny Boaz as Palmer Rudland

Alyshia Ochse as Julia Rudland

Havana Blum as Linnea Rudland

Seaton Stanley as Cooper Rudland

Chase Stokes as Russell Bennett

Carrie Anne Hunt as Young Lovie

David Moncrief as Richard Devries

Selena Anduze as Dr. Pittman

Anthony Triceri as Order Guy

Meiyee Apple Tam as Assistant

Haviland Stillwell as Biologist

Michael Burnett as Turtle (puppeteer)

Shelby Christine Freeman as Pregnant Girl (uncredited)

Luna Munroe as Pregnant Girl / Hurricane Evacuee (uncredited)

Michael Wayne Thomas as Boater (uncredited)

Lynne Burnett as Turtles (puppeteer) (uncredited)