Abby Ryder Fortson as Margaret Simon

Rachel McAdams as Barbara Simon

Kathy Bates as Sylvia Simon

Elle Graham as Nancy Wheeler

Benny Safdie as Herbert Simon

Amari Alexis Price as Janie Loomis

Katherine Mallen Kupferer as Gretchen Potter

Kate MacCluggage as Mrs. Jan Wheeler

Aidan Wojtak-Hissong as Moose Freed

Landon S. Baxter as Evan Wheeler

Echo Kellum as Mr. Benedict

Mia Dillon as Mary Hutchins

Gary Houston as Paul Hutchins

Mackenzie Joy Potter as Mamma Bunny

Olivia Williams as Witch

Mike Platarote Jr. as Guy in Car

Simms May as Norman Fisher

Zack Brooks as Philip Leroy

JeCobi Swain as Freddy Barnett

Wilbur Fitzgerald as Morris Binamin

Ethan McDowell as Mr. Wheeler

Sloane Warren as Mrs. Fisher

Isol Young as Laura Danker

Eden Lee as PTA Mother

Naida Nelson as PTA Mother

Tahirah Harrison as PTA Mother

Zach Humphrey as Salvation Army Guy

Karen Aruj as Department Store Sales Lady

Judy Blume as Neighbor Walking Dog #1

George Cooper as Neighbor Walking Dog #2

Joan Jackson as Neighbor

Stephen Jackson as Neighbor

Robert Haulbrook as Rough Looking Guy on Bus

Johnny Land as The General

Jennifer Errington as New York Restaurant Waitress

Evan Bergman as Greg the Greeter

Michael Wolk as Rabbi Kellerman

Karen Macarah as Cantor

Ariel DiDonato as Aliyah

Claude Deuce as Gospel Singer / Pastor

Keya Hamilton as Gospel Singer

Tanya J. McClellan as Mrs. Loomis

Dennis Delamar as Mailman

Samantha LeBrocq as Mrs. Potter

Wally White as Protestant Minister

Holli Saperstein as Mrs. Webster

Deborah Helms as Sweet Old Lady Cashier

Cooper Herrett as 17 Year Old Cashier

Gezell Fleming as School Librarian

Jim France as Catholic Priest

Rakeem Massingill as Art Student

Mary Clare Mitchell as Pedestrian