Steve Guttenberg as Nicholas Claus

Crystal Bernard as Elizabeth "Beth" Sawtelle

Dominic Scott Kay as Jake Swatelle

Thomas Calabro as Andrew

Armin Shimerman as Ernest

Sebastian Tillinger as Hennesy

Wendy Braun as Amy

Kelley Hazen as Joanie

Mackenzie Fitzgerald as Jocelyn

Cody Arens as Christian

Robin Shorr as Meredith

John Wheeler as Santa

Taffy Wallace as Coach

Samantha Bennett as Marilyn

Ashlynn Bernard as Young Beth

Katia Coe as Holly

Clement von Franckenstein as Sir John

Marcia Ann Burrs as Mrs. Clauss

Miranda Gibson as Emily

Hannah Wilber as Hearing Impaired Girl

Austin Miles as Mall Santa

Darby Stanchfield as Store Clerk

Diane Robin as Woman Customer

Erik Carr as Connor

Alison McMillan as Mom of Hearing Impaired Girl

Frank Sharp as Tree Seller

Brandon Keener as Commercial 1st AD

Mariette Hartley as Joanna

Staci Armao as (Uncredited / voice)

Blaise Brooks as Basketball Fan (uncredited)

S. Zev Esquenazi as Production Assistant (uncredited)

Dassler Jimenez as Elf (uncredited)

David Rasner as Various Voices (uncredited)