Claudette Colbert as Barbara Clarke

Fred MacMurray as Roger Coverman

Harvey Stephens as Dr. John Harding

Gale Sondergaard as Martha Harding

Louise Dresser as Ellen Clarke

Benny Bartlett as Timothy

Edward Ellis as Elder Goode

Beulah Bondi as Abigail

Bonita Granville as Ann

Virginia Weidler as Nabby

Donald Meek as Ezra Cheeves

E. E. Clive as Bilge

Halliwell Hobbes as Jeremiah

Pedro de Cordoba as Mr. Morse

Madame Sul-Te-Wan as Tituba

Lucy Beaumont as Rebecca

Henry Kolker as Crown Chief Justice Laughton

William Farnum as Crown Justice Sewall

Ivan F. Simpson as Rev. Parris

Brandon Hurst as Tithing Man

Sterling Holloway as Miles Corbin

Zeffie Tilbury as Goody Hodgers

Babs Nelson as Baby Mercy Cheeves

Mary Treen as Susy Abbott

J. Farrell MacDonald as Captain of Ship

Stanley Fields as First Mate

Lionel Belmore as Tavern Keeper

Wally Albright as Jasper (Uncredited)

Vangie Beilby as Mother (Uncredited)

Chief John Big Tree as Indian Man (Uncredited)

Tom Brower as Salem Town Marshal (Uncredited)

Tommy Bupp as Little Boy (Uncredited)

Rosita Butler as Mary Watkins (Uncredited)

Madge Collins as Elizabeth (Uncredited)

Harry Cording as Guard (Uncredited)

Sidney D'Albrook as Hunter (Uncredited)

Jack Deery as Non-Commissioned Officer (Uncredited)

Harold Entwistle as Court Clerk (Uncredited)

Amelia Falleur as Sarah (Uncredited)

Colin Kenny as Hunter (Uncredited)

Grace Kern as Convict (Uncredited)

Clarence Kolb as Town Crier (Uncredited)

George Magrill as Sailor (Uncredited)

James A. Marcus as Sea Captain (Uncredited)

Charles McAvoy as Father (Uncredited)

Clive Morgan as Non-Commissioned Officer (Uncredited)

Harold Nelson as Judge (Uncredited)

John Power as Minister (Uncredited)

Jack Richardson as Sheriff (Uncredited)

Tom Ricketts as Giles Cory (Uncredited)

Kathryn Sheldon as Mrs. Deborah Cheeves (Uncredited)

Russell Simpson as Village Marshal (Uncredited)

John Graham Spacey as Businessman (Uncredited)

Hayden Stevenson as Deputy Marshal (Uncredited)

Colin Tapley as Roger's Friend (Uncredited)

Joseph R. Tozer as Clergyman (Uncredited)

Helen Westcott as Little Girl (Uncredited)

Ricca Allen as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Agnes Ayres as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Wilson Benge as Townsman (Uncredited)

Sidney Bracey as Townsman (Uncredited)

Fritzi Brunette as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Herbert Evans as Townsman (Uncredited)

Fryda Gagne as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Edith Hallor as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Frank Hammond as Townsman (Uncredited)

Carol Holloway as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Harold Howard as Townsman (Uncredited)

Ward Lane as Townsman (Uncredited)

Vera Lewis as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Billy O'Brien as Young Jasper (Uncredited)

Anne O'Neal as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Rita Owen as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Stella LeSaint as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Audrey Reynolds as Townswoman (Uncredited)

Allen D. Sewall as Townsman (Uncredited)

Walter Soderling as Townsman (Uncredited)

Al Stewart as Townsman (Uncredited)

William Wagner as Townsman (Uncredited)